The “C” Word
October 19th, 2007 by Tony
I’m amazed how loosely the media uses the word chef. The Food Network show Top Chef showed a dozen young “chefs†blind-tasting 30 ingredients or so, and the winner of the competition was only able to identify 4…most, in shame, less than 3. Chefs indeed! Culinary schools claim they train people to become chefs. Well that is bogus…unless, of course, a chef is someone that can identify only 4 ingredients in a blind test, is young and sexy, has swagger, possibly a tattoo or two, knows how to climb over people, loves attention, is not camera-shy, and can sous-vide foie gras. In Spain, the media has coined their young handsome wild-haired gastro-experimental chefs as the “next genius generationâ€; interestingly, they all refer to their childhood memories in the kitchen with mom and grandma as the beginning of it all. Chefs are now talked and written about like Hollywood stars; and the ones with greatest style – not necessarily content – get the most attention, however superficial it may be.
I teach people to become cooks - professional cooks. In fact, that is the only concept I devote my life to: learning how to cook. It takes much more than damn good cookin’ to become a chef, and it can only be learned through many years in the industry, and that’s a whole different story. But becoming a cook is, to my mind, far more genuine, far more about the food, far more about defining yourself now, forever. What fascinates me about the great chefs of the past such as Antonin Careme and Fernand Point is not so much what they accomplished as chefs, but how they defined themselves as cooks. What I would give to have been there when Careme was a teenager learning his craft. I’m sure I’d walk away with the secret of how a passionate boy so quickly and so deeply learned his art. He simply cooked!
It’s too bad cooks get very little attention. In fact, the media portrays them as either getting dumped on or rising meteorically, artificially, to superstardom, but nothing in-between. All our visiting chefs, the one’s we respect and invite to our school to talk to our students, emphasize slowing things down, not to be in any hurry to become a chef. Good, logical advice. Hope the tv producers, journalists, food critics, and even the public, one day give hard-working cooks the quality attention they deserve. There’s nothing wrong with the word “cookâ€, but I’m sure if we had a one syllable word for it in French, instead of cuisinier (four syllables), cooks’ professional and personal lives might improve dramatically overnight.
I’ll come back to this one, I promise.
Cheers (especially to the cooks & dishwashers out there),
Tony Minichiello, Cook Instructor
Re-published with permission from our partners, The Northwest Culinary Academy of Vancouver
Actually Tony…..the show Top Chef was on Bravo, not Food Network.
Bravo Tony!
It is quite shocking that the young chefs could only tell a maximum of four ingredients. More shocking is the Food Network having such inexperienced tasters on the show. I’m sure that any of the participants in your Serious Foodie courses could have done better than the “chefs” on the show. Taste and odour are known to evoke the deepest and most emotional memories — being able to only tell four or less only tells us how little of life the young chefs have lived.
I’ve often wondered where the Food Channel gets its programming?
Cheers, Dave
Tony it’s a great point you make about cooks and the bad spin they get - I live in Ireland and tire of the abuse of the term chef in the USA - it’s used like Dr. or Fr. would be as some sort of badge of honour when no study may have been done and no real meaning is associated with the term - any mickey mouse course could have been done or none and nobody would know how many years have been spent in a kitchen doing god knows what to earn that title. Also can we please give up on the Executive Chef? What in heavens name does that mean? Chef who no longer cooks and just advises? Or Head Chef? or CEO chef?
[…] Co-owner of Northwest Culinary Academy of Vancouver - Rouxbe’s newest partner. Click [here] to review part […]
Great !!!!!!!
I totally agree with you Tony. Having worked in professional kitchens and also having taught young eager students the basics of cooking, I too consider the “C” word to be much more than just a diploma from a culinary school. We can provide them with a basic knowledge base and a dictionary to be able to speak and understand the culinary argot, but talent, passion , hard work ,respect for the profession and years of training has no substitute.
I have worked with chefs that don’t know how to make a demi or a basic chcken stock the same way I have worked with colleagues that are incredibly creative but undisciplined.
In a world that is challenged with depleting food supplies, I firmly believe that chefs and cooks also have a social responsability .
We are only as strong as our weakest link .